Comments on: It’s Not Just Your Favorite Book… Twilight Series Theories - Your Source for Twilight News and Speculations Thu, 22 Mar 2018 09:05:22 +0000 hourly 1 By: Amber Tue, 31 Mar 2009 01:06:25 +0000 melissaturkey,Harry Potter has won SEVERAL awards,and yes,the series did deserve to win again!Like I was insulting your intelligence!All I was IMPLYING is that I know how to use capitols.Did I tell you to change your mind?NO!And I used “It actually gives you alot to think about…….” because I got from your comment that you were telling me to think,so I used that in mine to tell you the same.Do I insult everyone who disagrees with me?Hmmmm,let me think?NOOO!And just because people like Twilight does not mean that it deserves to be in the classics!Harry Potter has sold over 10x what Twilight has.Look it up.Did I say Dracula wasn’t a classic,no.I said that it is a classic because of the author.And also to add the year it was published,and still printed now?!THAT’S a classic!Did I ever really say that everyone can’t have an opinion?No,I said that Harry Potter is better than Twilight!One opinion!Among many. I gave one comment,and now everyone has to gang up on me.Sounds like to me you are trying to change my opinion!And do you not pay attention to the good response I gave Twilight?I said that Twilight,in my own words,is 7 1/2 stars.I could have been mean and said that it is 0 stars!I have read Twilight,and liked it,but nothing compares to Harry Potter!In my opinion this is what I think:
Harry Potter=Fantastic
And to everyone here,I never said I had anything against Twilight,I just wanted to say what I thought.To know my first opinion,look at #3.I did not want to say that I hated Twilight,just that I feel that Harry Potter will be the best in my eyes.If I hated Twilight,why would I be on a Twilight fan site?

By: Melissa(melissaturkey) Mon, 30 Mar 2009 23:20:35 +0000 Amber,

I said Dracula was a classic didnt I? Yes, I was putting it in the same context as the classics. I never said that Bram Stoker wasnt a brilliant writer and I never said that JK Rowling was anything less than AMAZING either. I love JK Rowling I love Harry Potter. I never said that Twilght was better. I like them the same, not because either is better written, I know Harry Potter is better written, but because people enjoy twilght too.

I never said Stephenie was better than them I just said that Twilight deserves its place in the classics too. Why? Because people like it. People love these characters, people love the story-even if it isnt as big or as great as the Harry Potter book/movie franchise but people talk about. Alot of people love it and isnt that the reason the “classics” are the “classics” because they are loved and talked about even now long after they were written? Isnt that the point? Dont you think that this generation of twilighters will pass on their love of the twilight series to their daughters, as really good books to read? No they’re not the best written books out there, yes they are a little corny and silly and cause alot of insane uproar in the fandom but PEOPLE LIKE THEM, you have to accept it and not insult everyone who thinks differently than you.

And I was not trying to be psychic when I made that comment about years down the line, nor was I saying that they arent already in the same isle because they are. I was merely saying that someday I believe they’ll both be classics because they are both popular and people do dearly love them as much as pervious generations have loved the classics that have came before.

I know that they are both fantasy, but my point was that they could almost be in different genres because Twilght is more a romance than anything, the main theme to the story is Bella and Edwards love even if other things get in the way of that whereas in Harry Potter its primarily about a young wizard fighting against dark forces in the wizarding world. It is different and whether people like one or the other better has to do with what genre they prefer fantasy/romance or fantasy/adventure.

Correct me if I’m wrong because I dont really keep up with all these awards too well but hasnt Harry Potter won this award before or at least many similar awards? Why should they deserve to have it again? Cant Twilght have one award in your mind? Does everyone else really have to “think better” can you let everyone have there own opinion and not barrel down there throats?

And finally did you have to insult my intelligence? I never insulted yours, nor did I even comment on anything you had to say before this or have any negative comment toward you. You didnt have a right to insult my intelligence because I didnt do anything to you. I stated my opinion. You dont have to agree with it but you dont have to insult me. I do know how to use capital letters thank you but this was a comment on an internet page, not an english assignment or a story, there is no reason to use all the correct grammer and punctuation. It’s just a comment and was it really necessary to through my words back into my face like that “It actually gives you alot to think about……” I didnt mean anything mean spirited when I wrote it, just that I was contemplating the matter and that it is actually an interesting topic thinking about all the books from this generation that could make it into the “classics.” You didnt have to use it the way you did.

I’m sorry that there are people here that disagree with you and yeah there are people that disagree with me but Im not going to insult them or tell them that they need to change their minds.

sorry if I offended you in any way but I had to defend myself. you dont have to reply to this and you dont have to take any of the things I said into consideration, I dont mean to change any of your opinions. I just wanted you to understand where I was coming from.

sincerely melissaturkey

By: Amber Mon, 30 Mar 2009 21:38:07 +0000 Brandi,you say not to be rude,but yet,you are!What is your definition of ‘rude’?Not nice to tell someone to go to a HP site and put down Twilight.Harry Potter is best,not Twilight.Cassidy,Twilight did not deserve the award!Everybody needs to think better!

By: Cassidy Mon, 30 Mar 2009 17:25:54 +0000 YAY YAY YAY YAY YAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I ran around the house so many times!!!! Twilight deserves this award!!!!

By: Brandi Mon, 30 Mar 2009 17:17:55 +0000 Lets all not be rude, but if you want to put down Twilight do it at a HP site NOT ours! This is exciteing i didn’t know Twilight was nom. Cool, can’t wait to see a vid of Taylor! :]

By: Victoria Mon, 30 Mar 2009 16:26:15 +0000 Sia,I don’t think that it was right to be so rude!Yes,some people like Twilight more than Harry Potter,but I really think that HP should have won!And Melissa,the two series are not in different genres,they are both in ‘Fantasy’!And I do think that Amber is right though…….

By: Amber Mon, 30 Mar 2009 16:20:12 +0000 PLEASE ‘melissaturkey’Dracula is a classic,yes.But why?The author.Bram Stoker was a brilliant writer,and will always be remembered as that.But Stephenie Meyer,she won’t be a classic writer!J.K. Rowling will be in history as one of the finest writers.Oh please,Twilight and Harry Potter in the same isle?’My grandchildren and great grandchildren could be walking down the isles of a Barnes and Noble or a Borders store and see all these stories in one section.’Spare me!What are you now,a psychic?Twilight won’t be a classic,the movies will not be a classic,so SORRY to crush your little dream!And don’t you know how to use capitols?Well,I guess this just proves that I am more intelligent!

It actually gives you alot to think about……

By: Melissa(melissaturkey) Mon, 30 Mar 2009 05:43:30 +0000 On the subject of classics my first thought was that twilight could not reach the classic status of Pride and Prejudice and Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story and things like that (or at least not the same section of classic literature) as it has vampires in it but then I thought of Dracula. There is a twisted romance in that, with Mina and all that craziness. It occurs to be that one day my grandchildren and great grandchilden could be walking down the isles of a barnes and noble or a borders store and see all these stories in one section, a catagory all of there own Pride and Prejudice, Romeo and Juliet, Dracula, Twilght and Harry Potter all in one isle for easy access to “classical” literature. Its funny how that might turn out and then next they would be compairing Romeo and Juliet to Dracula and Mina (which is quite an interesting compairison dont you think?) who are on the surface as different as Harry Potter and Twilight.

it actually gives you alot to think about…

😀 melissaturkey

By: Rachel Mon, 30 Mar 2009 03:54:08 +0000 I <3 Taylor

FANS! we need to come up with a cool name for Taylor Lautner like Robert Pattinson being R-Patz


Jazz (Team Cullen!)

By: ashleycullen Sun, 29 Mar 2009 23:04:40 +0000 oh yea! i SOO knew Twilight would win! GO TWILIGHT!!!!!

By: Barbie Sun, 29 Mar 2009 21:32:40 +0000 btw amber…
i think twilight will be a classic.
recap the last clasics
pride and prejudice, romeo and juliet les misarebles ect ect
doesnt twilight just fit the criteria to be the next classic???
but that is my opinion.

By: Barbie Sun, 29 Mar 2009 21:25:56 +0000 EHMAGAWD! that was the only reason i watched the kids choise awards.
I screamed so loud! and i saw Taylor [[he is ssssoooo! HAWT!]] was receving the award! and i started screaming again!
then i called my friend to rub it in her face!!!
CONGRATZ Stephenie!!!

By: Lola Sun, 29 Mar 2009 19:13:14 +0000 YAY!

By: Amber Sun, 29 Mar 2009 18:47:01 +0000 ‘Sia’,did I mention how much Harry Potter sold?NO!The only reason Twilight won was because of the new movie!Harry Potter won last year,and Order of the Phoenix and the books after,are not boring,Briony!Harry Potter is top,and will always be!Which do you think will be a classic?Harry Potter or Twilight?I mean come on!Is it not obvious?!Everyone has their one opinion,and mine is this:
Harry Potter-10 Stars**********
Twilight-7 1/2 Stars*******

By: Briony Sun, 29 Mar 2009 18:19:09 +0000 I would say Harry Potter COULDN’T win because it’s best series, right? If it was , say, ‘Best First Book’ I think Harry would win, but the lastfew books (Order of the Phoenix onwards) got kind of repetitive, long-winded and dull, whereas in my opinion each Twilight book was better than its predecessor.

Plus, Harry Potter has no Jasper, Jacob or Emmet. So really, how could it win?

By: Alecia Sun, 29 Mar 2009 17:22:36 +0000 I screamed when it won!!!!

By: Shteff Sun, 29 Mar 2009 16:53:38 +0000 XD My friend is killing me as I type this!
She’s like, a number one harry potter fan 😀 so its me vs her, and due forth the scratches she’s inflicting are proof of her anger LMFAO!
but heck, no sliming? poo!

By: hannah Sun, 29 Mar 2009 16:51:23 +0000 omg i knew twilight would win! and i couldnt even get all the way through harry potter when i read it

By: Skye Sun, 29 Mar 2009 16:48:05 +0000 I voted for Harry Potter.