Comments on: Will Jeff Buckley Biopic Include Rob?

By: Sally Taylor

Sally Taylor — Sun, 23 Jan 2011 22:09:25 +0000

I think Rob would be fantastic as Jeff he’s a great singer – get over Twilight he’s done loads of other films and he will be so committed to this film. I hope they give him the chance to prove himself. My vote is definitely for Rob

By: Emma

Emma — Sun, 16 Jan 2011 16:32:06 +0000

“and it really doesn’t matter what jeff would have thought anyway. he’s dead. and if it’s a terrible movie the world will go on, just like it does when every other shitty movie about famous people comes out.”

Yes it does bloody well matter what Jeff would have thought. It’s HIS life they are wanting to put out there……or at least other peoples memories and versions of who they thought he was. Have some respect. People matter, memories of those people matter.

You have so much hate and bitterness built up in you, and while I understand the need to “spew” once in a while……I hope you have other, better ways of dealing with stress also, otherwise in the end, you end up, if you are lucky and realize it in time to change – you end up not liking what the “beatings” of life have pushed you to become.

As for his mother……no one can really know her motives if they don’t know HER. (my mom’s been dead 11 years and even some of her own friends still don’t know how violent and abusive she was)………

Jeff had his own response for Sony’s intentions……

What I see, and this is only my opinion is a woman who does not want her son forgotten, who may never be able to deal with his death. & accepting that he is not here anymore. What parent would? Everyone has different ways of dealing with pain and loss – and since we are all different in how we react to things, externally , internally……each one of us can see/experience the same event & you could easily have one person collapse from it, one person shut themselves away, one person saying “what is the big deal”……

In an interview with her I saw she said she hoped Jeff would be proud of her…….did anyone ever think that she feels she failed him in some way and is trying desperately to make amends? We’ve all done it. The “if I would have been there”, “if I had listened more”, “if I had done, or not done, this or that”…if….if……if……..

Grief has no time limit…….if you were not still grieving the loss of a child, in some way, no matter how big or how small……you were not a mom or dad……

I’m not saying I agree with what’s going on or that I don’t agree……..but there are more paths to this situation than we can see.

By: Tom

Tom — Thu, 02 Dec 2010 00:00:46 +0000

James Franco can actually sing and let’s be fair, is a much better actor. I fear that Rob would teenify the whole concept and get a load of silly twilight fans listening to Jeff to look cool. This wouldn’t really bother me to be honest but I genuinely believe using James would be so much better. Or Emile hirsch! He’s great.

By: Samantha

Samantha — Fri, 09 Jul 2010 03:27:08 +0000

No. No. Absolutely no.
If they cast Robert Pattinson, they might as well send it straight to DVD…and then put it in the bargain bin.
Let’s have a little respect for Jeff, please?
I would love it if a complete unknown were to get the role. I’ve always thought that if you cast a big name in a movie, you’re focusing on the actor and not the character.
Now it’s fine to cast these “hot commodities” in movies aimed towards a younger audience, because that’s what will draw them in. But for Jeff’s audience, that’s not gonna work. I think it will have the opposite effect.
They need to create a really honest film, which reflects his life without all the “tortured soul” crap.

By: Jeff Buckle Fan

Jeff Buckle Fan — Sun, 02 May 2010 00:07:47 +0000

haha..nice one. i love you for saying that.

By: Harry

Harry — Sun, 14 Feb 2010 18:27:10 +0000

Ben Whishaw should pplay Jeff Buckley. That’d sort it so it’s not a shit film. He’d be great & very true to what happened.

By: killdozer

killdozer — Fri, 25 Dec 2009 07:55:26 +0000

mooster: “Pity his mother’s so greedy.”

FUCK you. his mother was very reluctant to agree to the movie. and it really doesn’t matter what jeff would have thought anyway. he’s dead. and if it’s a terrible movie the world will go on, just like it does when every other shitty movie about famous people comes out. it won’t hurt for people who care about his legacy to try making a film about him and if it’s bad it won’t affect the fact that he was one of the greatest musicians ever. you know what probably WOULD make jeff shudder in his grave? someone TALKING SHIT ABOUT HIS MOTHER.

By: Matt

Matt — Tue, 22 Dec 2009 10:28:08 +0000

Why can’t a unknown like myself play Jeff Buckley? Being that Jeff was so close to cracking the big time but never really quite got there for eg no one really knew who he was until all of the press and media coverage surrounding his death and the use of ‘Hallejuah’ in several circles of film and television.

I’ve spoken a few times over the years with Mary Guibert about his music and doing the Buckley tribute shows for 11 years now in Sydney, Australia.

If you need the proof, watch the vid… mind you, not the best version I’ve ever done but hey, chop the hair off my head and my chin… I’ve already lost the weight lol… what do you think?? I leave it for you lovely people to decide…

By: Kasey

Kasey — Sun, 08 Nov 2009 20:57:43 +0000

I think the choice is obvious. Buckley was never one for mainstream. Pattison might be able to sing, but let’s be honest, who can sing like Buckley? Franco is a dead ringer, and an extremely talented actor. Also, I’m fairly certain Jeff might vomit at the idea of “the Twilight guy” playing his life story! I find it hard to believe the hardcore Buckley fans would ever support Pattison, the only people who would come see the movie would be teenage Twilight fans.

By: krittenslurv

krittenslurv — Tue, 18 Aug 2009 16:29:57 +0000

p.s. mooster-I think his mom knows him better than you do…I think a film is a great idea if it’s well made…
it will bring a whole new generation of buckley fans like walk the line did for johnny cash…
and rpattz really is a good actor.. don’t just judge him on twilight. Watch How To Be. It’s a fantastic indie british film. Trust me, it’s worth it.

By: krittenslurv

krittenslurv — Tue, 18 Aug 2009 16:28:16 +0000

I think James Franco and Robert Pattinson are both fantastic actors and I adore both of them…
I think Franco looks more like Buckley, but Rob is a musician…I’d have to hear them both singing Buckley songs to really form
an opinion

By: Betti. Music. Twilight.

Betti. Music. Twilight. — Thu, 11 Jun 2009 12:22:56 +0000

a singer’s POV on this,
plus: sound examples of them both for you to judge:

http://bettimusictwilight.blogspot.com/2009/06/rob-pattinson-jeff-buckley.html

By: mooster

mooster — Wed, 10 Jun 2009 21:07:14 +0000

Jeff Buckley will shudder in his grave if this film gets off the ground. No one should play Jeff. Jeff already did that. Pity his mother’s so greedy. She’ll probably cast RPattz just to get the dollars from all those millions of twifans who’ve never heard of (or heard) her son. Face it, if RPattz’s cast the film will be a blockbuster despite how fucking awful it is. Jeff hated the internet, he hated being tracked like Rob is being, he hated all the li’l girls that chased after him when he was alive (much like RPattz) and he would HATE that this film is being made at all. Shame on his mother.

By: Kel

Kel — Mon, 08 Jun 2009 01:19:09 +0000

As much as I love Rob, I think James Franco is more appropriate for the role. As for James Marsden and Jared Leto, they’re both in their mid-30′s and Buckley died at age 30. Maybe Rob would be good for a secondary role, if the film gets made. Just my opinion.

By: haylie

haylie — Sat, 06 Jun 2009 02:46:07 +0000

james franco has jeff buckley eyes. its almost ridiculous.

By: Taryn

Taryn — Sat, 06 Jun 2009 01:29:26 +0000

Let Rob have a crack at it! Who else would understand sudden fame so well? This is what the movie will focus on people & all the weirdness that must come with that. Plus, let us not forget the passion required to play Jeff.I don’t see James Franco doing Jeff much justice(although he is an amazing actor) I just think something more magical would come out of Rob for some reason…like it is a role meant for him. He may not exactly look like Jeff but I’m just saying, there’s something there.

By: my-personal-brand-of-heroin

my-personal-brand-of-heroin — Fri, 05 Jun 2009 23:23:12 +0000

rob has got the right style of voice its so soulful
its more than just the right looks

By: probabaly the second biggest twilight freak in the world

probabaly the second biggest twilight freak in the world — Fri, 05 Jun 2009 20:29:18 +0000

have u seen jeff buckleys album cover of hallelujah? rob looks exactly like that! and robs sings amazingly and im sure he could sing b#more like jeff if he wanted to and also i think rob acts ore like jeff than james does and how many biopics can james do!? like someone up there said.
jared leto would be good but he doesnt look alot like him.
i just think rob has all the factors to be jeff and hes so hot for films at the moment he wold just be perfect!

By: Judith Akufo

Judith Akufo — Fri, 05 Jun 2009 17:57:03 +0000

James Franco is a dead ringer, sorry Rob

By: Michy.

Michy. — Fri, 05 Jun 2009 14:33:48 +0000

JAMES FRANCO!! sorry Rob!