Question of the Week ~ Who will die?
Jun 20th, 2008 | By Kallieross | Category: Question of the WeekIt is that time again! This week are are asking you a ‘terminal’ question… who will you be giving a death sentence to?
-
Ads & Sponsors
-
Books
Ads & Sponsors
Browse Archives
December 2014 November 2014 June 2014 February 2014 January 2014 November 2013 October 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 May 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009 February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008 August 2008 July 2008 June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008Search Archives
I think that balla will die………………………………….ya know become a vampire!! Edward will finally bite her. thats what i think.
I think one of the humans will be sacrificed in order for Bella to become a vampire. I think that’s what the red pawn in the cover of Breaking Dawn represents; red is for the blood and it’s a pawn which means it will protect the queen (Bella). I think this human will be either Jacob or Sam. Jacob because he is the most likely to sacrifice himself in order for her to live and Sam because if he dies then Jacob is bound to come back. I don’t really want it to be either of them since I like Sam and I don’t really want Jacob to die, mainly because I like the idea of him and Leah together. However, i’m leaning toward Jacob being a goner by the end of Breaking Dawn…
That way he can protect her as much as she can, but in the end she will be wounded and will need to become a vampire. However, the pawn may mean that, if Sam dies and Jacob comes back, he will do everything in his power to stop Bella from becoming a vampire thus protecting her. But, since the queen is white as opposed to the red pawn, I am pretty sure that Bella will be a vampire in the end.
I just hope none of the Cullens bite it, no pun intended, especially not Edward because I could never read Twilight again knowing that Edward would not survive. It would be heart Breaking.
I do like the theory that Kassie gave out a while ago about Rosalie being ‘scared’ while protecting Bella, I think that would be amazing.
This is a huge question isn’t it? If she takes a page out of JKR’s book, then she’ll kill half the cast of characters. This, I hope, is not the case.
If I had to guess, I would say Sam will die. It makes sense that he would, because of the mention that Jacob is the real Alpha. Since Jacob ran off, it would be a good reason for him to come back.
I can’t really subscribe to the Rosalie theory, but it is possible. I also think that Billy Black might die. He is a small character, but with his disability, he is made an easy target for the blood thirsty.
The book cover is confusing to me and I feel that Bella may be the pawn. If you think about it, the Volturi are using her in their game. Using her like a pawn. This opens the door to death and destruction. Most of my theory is just something I came up with now. Sorry if it sucks. =)
I’m not sure who will die, but I don’t think it will be a Cullen because vampires are so HARD to kill. It’d be really hard for one of them to be killed without the others taking action. Plus they all have so much experience. On the other hand, the werewolves are only human and, even though they’re just as strong as vampires, they can be killed FASTER. Also, they may have instinct, but so do most vampires, and they don’t have the years of experience that a lot of vampires do, especially the Volturi. If they’re to be the antagonist then the werewolves have a huge disadvantage in durability, experience, and numbers. Whereas the Cullens only have the numbers disadvantage. Seth is my top bet no matter how much i love him.
It’s a very complex theory, but there you have it.
ok i think evry1 will die(like a Shakespearian tradgedy):
jacob will run into some vamps and try 2 fight them but dies in the process then sam sends all the wolves(except seth)to go get him-try to save him.that doesnt work cause there are too many vamps and r too powerful so they all get killed. bella hears about this and flips out(bella was already turned into a vamp) so edward says lets go see if we can help(cause he cant stand to c bella like this) so they go and find jacob on the way bella is happy but jacob doesnt kno its her so he attacks and edward gets killed for protecting her @ that moment jacob turns back into a human and sees bella sobbing tearless sobs.he is mad @ himself and goes ovr 2 bella to console her but the rest of the vamps attack jacob and kill him but emment tried to protect rosalie and they both were killed. so bella,jasper,alice,carisle,and esme go on but they are all as depressed as a vamp can get. they meet up w/the other vamps and fight but every1 else dies except for bella who goes back to the cullens house gets a picture of edward and heads off to italy when she gets there she goes to the same spot edward was when he tried to kill himself so she does the same thing but no1 stops her cause there is no1 left she gets attacked by the voturi and killed. she does go to heaven and right behind the gates is edward waiting for her and she starts to cry and so does he(because they r dead they r no longer vamps).they r very happy cause now edward can be a human now, which means they both have feelings and live happily ever after! and the only person left living is seth who tells the story of, the girl who loved a vampire and a werewolf.
THE END=]
I know that no one wants to hear this but I think that Edward or Bella or both will eventually have to die. She has mirrored these books after so many tragedies that it would be off if she didn’t keep them apart in the long run. I know that a lot of people don’t want this but if she does kill one of them off it will be poetic and beautiful in its own way.
I think that it will also show people the finality of true love and that even in death its still there but she could also use the symbolism of Bella becoming a vampire as the person in the story dying.
i think every1 will die like in a Shakespearian tradgedy!
ok jacob is in trouble so the wolves go help but there is like this huge mass of vamps so they kill them but almost every1 dies but jacob. bella is mildly upset cause she knows who she cant live without so the other cullens go help. while there the volturi see them and attack because they r jealous of the cullens. the cullens die(except 4 edward and bella) bella is upset and charlie sees that so she is forced to tel him what is going on. he flips out and has a heart attack and dies. jessica,mike,angela,be,and austin are in a car goin to the funeral and are in a fatal car crash and die. renee and paul tried cliff diving and hit another cliff on their way down and die. bella is very upset. jacob comes by but sees that edward is consoling her and she was already turned into a vamp and he knos she loves edward more. he goes to a vampire clan and they kill him. bella never found out about this.so bella and edward r the only ones left and they are as depressed as a vampire can get so they agree to go to italy. they stoood in the same spot edward did when he was doing this. edward and bella are killed by the volturi but there is a heaven 4 vamps. they live happily together in the after-life. the only one left to tell their story is Billy Black. he tells the story of, the girl who loved a vampire and a werewolf.
THE END=]
Ok, so I think that Edward will “die.” Hold on and listen for a second cause I’m an Edward fan and I don’t want this to happen.
I think that right before Edward is about to change Bella she will think about everything that she is giving up, and tell Edward that she needs more time.
Alice will then have a vision showing Bella won’t be a vampire because she changed her mind. Edward will read Alice’s mind and realize this, and assume it’s because Bella has chosen Jake.
In the final battle with the Volturi the Cullens will fight with the wolves. Jake will be in trouble during the fight and almost die. Edward, wanting Bella to be happy, saves Jake and gets torn apart by one of the Volturi.
Bella will be so depressed that Edward “died” that she will realize that she wanted to be with Edward all along.
When the Volturi have been driven away, Edward’s remains and ashes will begin to reconstruct themselves, just like in the Quilette legend. (When will those Quilettes realize that ALL of the legends are true) Once Edward is all in one piece Bella will be turned into a vampire, and Jake will finally understand how much Bella really loves Edward and let her be happy. =)
I have a feeling that one of the Cullen family members is going to dye. or Jacob or Bella or Edward…. yeah… I don’t know how they will die. They might dye during a battle of some sort.
I think the only characters that will die will be very minor characters that no one really cares about. Stephenie is too much of a sentimentalist and too attached to her characters to let them die. Just about all of the main characters are in a serious relationship, so killing any one person would devastate his/her mate, and I just don’t think Stephenie could handle such sadness in her characters! I think an author usually kills off a character to a) enhance the plot or b) to make the story realistic (like JK Rowling!). I don’t see how a character death would enhance Breaking Dawn’s plot (other than Sam’s death could trigger Jacob becoming the head of the pack, but there are so many other ways Stephenie could make Jacob return without Sam’s death); and I don’t think Stephenie cares about making her story realistic. Her books are all about having a good reading experience and exploring the minds of her superhuman characters.
Has Stephenie said there is going to be a character death in Breaking Dawn? If she has, I feel silly… :p
I really don’t think that EVERYONE will die, cus that would be so sad and everyone would be sad, and Stephenie Meyer said that this is the ending she thought it should always have and she thinks everyone will probably be pretty happy. I mean, I know you can’t make everyone happy, but ya know. Kinda make sense?
Why do people have to die?
No one is going to die. No way. José.
Stephenie has said repeatedly that she doesn’t like sad endings, so if anyone is going to die it’s going to be someone
I think Leah’s going to die and that it will stir up the EmilyxSamxLeah love triangle, by having Sam die with her. Or I think Sam is going to die saving Leah, and then she’ll die seeking revenge or something.
On a different note, I also think Seth will die, and his death will bring the vampire’s and werewolves together finally (like maybe he’ll die saving Edward/Alice)
AGH. Sorry, I accidently submitted my thing too soon.
Continued:
It’s going to be someone who’s a bad guy.
The Cullen’s are too important to kill off, and if she kills off any one of them it will be too tragic.
Same with the werewolves.
It just wouldn’t work. At. All.
According to an interview with Stephenie Meyer, Bella and Edward will live, as well as Alice and Jasper. But it was not confirmed that the other Cullens are going to “survive”. As much as I dread this fact, I think it’s going to be Carlisle who is going to die, just because I see Edward as a second Carlisle, and though he’ll never be able to completely fill his shoes as head of the coven, he has most of his good qualities like massive restraint, compassion, knowledge, etc.
I also see Sam dying, I don’t have this aversion to group leaders, but it just makes sense for me to have him die and make Jacob the head of the pack. Even though Bella has already made a decision on who she’s going to spend her existence with, the idea that two powerful group heads fighting over the love of a woman would be fascinating. (She’s still not turned into a vampire anyway, and who knows what twists Stephenie will include in Breaking Dawn.)
I’ve had this feeling for awhile that it will be Emmett. It makes for a tragic storyline as well as a good plot device…maybe during the battle scene between the Volturi/Werewolves/Cullens, Emmett will defend Bella or prevent Bella from a situation that will leave her getting hurt/killed and end up getting killed himself…I know this seems like a pretty weak theory, maybe the situation will be different but I have this feeling that Edward will lose his brother. Stephenie has told things to many of the cast about their upcoming storylines in Breaking Dawn but it seemed she talked especially hard to Kellan Lutz, almost as if his role in the book was a pivotal life altering one. It sounds crazy! But thats my theory….or maybe I’ve been reading too much fan fiction?!
I really love the show, you guys are making senior year a lot more easier to cope with. In my breaks at home or at school inbetween studying I’ll often put my headphones on and switch on one of your weeks disccusions and I find myself being taken away from all the stress and madness. Please keep the shows coming. xoxo
Why is that that someone HAS to die? I hope SM doesn’t kill off any characters.. it’ll make Twilight seem even more cliche than it is.
I understand how characters died in HP, but we knew it was coming.. it was always predicted at there was going to be a huge war between Harry and Voldemort and some people were going to die. What’s going to happen in Twilight? Voulturi/Tanya/Jacob issues? Twilight, I feel, is more of a light read which mainly serves to bring pleasure. Why is it that stories nowadays always have a death/s in it? Gahhhhhhhhhhh, please no deaths! Don’t make Twilight cliche!! PLEASE!!
kvjshlkgh;sio sorry, i didn’t intend to sound rude, criticise or bring up Harry Potter.
Okay so I think that there is a high possiblitly that Jacob or Emmett may die. Jacob would die batteling for Bella’s saftey, as would Emmett, thought Jacob would be soley protecting Bella, whereas Emmett would be protecting all his family. Bella has referred to Emmett charging in to a situation without paying proper attention before (see Eclipse) and I worry that it could happen in Breaking Dawn. Emmett has always been the character that is enthusiastic and bright and cheery in almost every situation; the only time I can think of where this was not the case was in New Moon with Jasper trying to attack Bella. I think Stephanie Meyer will remove that part of the Cullen family, to show how much the Cullens relied on Emmett; I feel he’s kind of a character that people see as a funny plot device sometimes (or maybe I just have read too many fanfictions like that) and Emmett is so much more then that. He is one of my favourite Cullens (after Edward, Jasper and Alice) and I really don’t want him to die!
I don’t want Jacob to die either (even though I’m totally team Edward and really don’t like Jacob) but I’d rather he’d imprint. He needs a nice girl to help him get over Bella :]
This is kinda off the point but … if Bella died (which I don’t think she will) then I think Edward wouldn’t go to Volturi to kill himself; he would go to wolf pack. All he would need to do is cross the line into La Push and the wolves would kill him. Gosh I feel so morbid talking about my favourite characters dieing! I hope that none of them die 😀
Okay, I kinda hate/kinda love this theory. Mkay, so I think that Bellas power is gonna be obsobtion, so i think she will then use this power to kill one of the Voturi for trying to hurt Jake in some way. I think teh Volturi will inturupt the weding, find Jacob there and eventually try to attack him. Bella will be changed by then and she will use her powers against them, Jane’s in particular, and hold them against their will. While they are imobile she will rip them to shreds and burn them. I hate Jake, too, but Bella loves him (-gags-) so i think she would do this if someone tried to hurt him. -Nick
I think Jacob or Tanya will die for two reasons, 1. I HATE Jacob! I really don’t care for Tanya either. 2. If Stephenie Meyer has to kill off any characters, which I really hope she doesn’t because that would be sad, she would probably kill off one that hasn’t been in the story for a while or that has left.
Jacob I guess would probably run into Tanya, and imprint on her then she gets really ticked and kills Jacob, because Tanya found out the Jacob was a werewolf. Then Tanya goes to the Volturi and tells them about the werewolves, but someone in the Volturi kills Tanya, because they thought they should.
Okay, lame excuse, but I have no idea if anyone will die, so yeah, there’s my answer!
I think that Sam will die and Jake will have to take his place as the alpha dog.
i think it will be sam! cause he is not MAIN characters and if jake or edward or i dare say emmet die the book would be stupid and I would chuck it across the room and scream!!!
srry!
but if sam dies i think jake will take alpha and leah will be the other pack leader cuase she is in love with jake!!!
okay tha it who i think will die!!
Ok, Before I start I have two theories the first I am sceptical about. The other one I
I’m another “older” Twilight fan, so I really appreciate your podcasts!
I think if you read The Host you get the idea that Stephenie Meyer likes her happy endings. If she’s going to kill off favorite characters I don’t think she’s saving it up for her teen series. I like that about her, not every book has to have a ton of traumatic deaths a la Harry Potter. Characters do die, James, Harry Clearwater, Laurant, etc, but they tend to be minor or enemy characters. I just don’t see that trend ending in Breaking Dawn.
So who do I think will perish? I agree that Sam is a likely character, as the books have hinted that Jacob is the more powerful werewolf. But I honestly think that the werewolf in most danger is the hot headed Paul.
On the vampire side, I think Jane may meet her end. She is a danger to Bella, for if the Volturi come and Bella does have a super power, then that will make Jane jealous. We already saw in New Moon that she does not like to share the spotlight. It’s also possible that other members of the Volturi will be at risk, as they are all pretty expendable. Really, will you shed any tears if Marcus or Aro dies? I didn’t think so.
I am sure that the main characters are safe. Stephenie seems like a sweetheart who is a sucker for happy endings, I think she’ll give us ours too.
Ok I have two theories for who will die. One is actually from my friend who didn’t have time to post. The first one is from the friend.
She thinks that Bella will die but not on purpose in an accident. She thinks this because, then Stephenie Meyer woudn’t have to choose which way Bella should go and who she would be with. Then she would leave it up to us to think of what would happen with the vampiers and werewolfs.
That I am not sure about but she asked me to post it for her this is mine.
I think that Jake would die. This is not only because I dispise Jake but because to be it is the only thing that would make sience. Jake ranaway but I think he may come back when Bella is in danger and Edward can’t get to her and Jake would be there and protect Bella and die saving her. That is who my friend and I think would die if anyone would. Oh I Love your Show Thanks!!! Sam.
I think eather Billy or Charlie will die because there not so big the story will be ruined but big enough to make a big impact. Everyone would end up crying if one of them die.
I think that if Charlie dies it will be because some how he found out about the whole vampire thing and tried to save her frome someone like the Vulturi and gets himself killed. that would emotionly hurt bella though so I dont know if Stephenie could do that to her
If Billy dies he would probably die from one of the werewolf like trying to hold him/her back and they get too angry and change killing him … or he could die from old age or a heart attack like Henry did and Bella would feel bad and she would come and try to comfort Jacob starting a whole new chapter in her life … hmm thats one hard thing deciding who will die. I feel bad now because I love them both
I think that Edward, Bella and Jacob are going to die. You know how New Moon was based on Romeo and Juliet? Well I have a feeling that Stephenie Meyer may end the series the way that Shakespeare ended Romeo and Juliet. They are both going to die because of each other and because of Jacobs love for Bella. The ending will probably be tearful on my end anyway! haha
i think that bella is gonna “die” in the sense because she will become a vampire, and i think that jacob might die trying to save bella from something because he loves her so much.
i think that bella will become depressed and blame herself for jacob’s death but will still become a vampire and marry edward.
Rereading Millay’s quote, I think the person to die will be someone who will end Bella’s childhood, someone extremely close to her, someone who was a part of her childhood. I think it will be one of her parents. I don’t think it’ll be at the wedding though although it could be. But I see Bella becoming a vampire after the wedding, so maybe some of the volturi will be watching the wedding and see most of the cullens away and decide to make trouble (a la Midsummer Night’s Dream) and does so by killing a parent. One of them will be killed by a vampire, which forces the pack into action, well not “forces”. This will involve the volturi (although not the full force, just some errant minor guards, jane, Demetri, Felix, Gianna, Alec, and maybe/not Caius) and bring in the denali coven for an all out war. With the fight against the volturi, Denali will see the pack as being weak so that’s while they’ll jump in. This will force the Cullens to choose where their loyalties lie. Maybe the parent would just be bitten and saved similar to Bella’s saving in Twilight. I’m not sure.
Unfortunately, I also think it’s a possibility that Billy or Sam would die, which would be horrible. I see Billy and Sue getting together and Sam and Emily marrying. I’d hate it if any of the La Push characters die.
This being said, i don’t want anyone to die. I want the happy ending.
I think whoever dies is either someone from the pack, Edward, Charlie, or Bella. I thought it would be her at first, because it is the last book that she is the narrator, but then again, she is narrating it. The person who dies can’t know what goes on for the rest of the book, can she?
I think it could be Charlie, because enemies might attack a human Bella loves.
It could be someone from the wolf pack, but that one’s just a guess.
Edward might die saving Bella or someone… Hopefully he wouldn’t!! 🙂
if (big emphasis on the if) someone were to die, which probably will happen since there is alot of drama in these books, I don’t think it will be one of the Cullens. That’s because I don’t want them to die, but for the people that do think one of the Cullens will die, I can see where they’re coming from. I think it will be Jacob who will die. Jacob comes back after the wedding is over. He’ll find out that Edward will turn Bella into a vampire on their honeymoon, Jacob finds out where Edward and Bella are at, but he won’t stop Edward from turning her, since in Eclipse he says he would be the good guy and let her be with Edward, Jacob just wants to be there for a goodbye to the human Bella. While he’s on his way the Volturi come to find Edward and Bella to check on them since they herd that they got married. But the Volturi find out from the Denali clan that there are werewolves in Forks. They would just talk to Edward about it since they’re going to talk to him and Bella anyway. On their way they see Jacob in his wolf form and they decide to talk to him. Jacob refuses since he is in a hurry to see Bella before she is turned. They fight, Jacob kills one of the Volturi members and Jane is in that group and gets furious and kills Jacob. Bella wakes up after she is turned and finds out that Jacob is dead, she wants to go to his funeral. So the werewolves drop the treaty. Then the Cullens find out that they want to get rid of the werewolves for killing a Volturi member. The Cullens and werewolves team up again to fight against the Volturi. Bella is stonger than any of the vampires and werewolves, the Cullens and werewolves win the fight , and that’s how Bella’s power and Jacob’s death will play into the story.
I’m terrified that Alice or Edward will die. I’m also terrified that Bella won’t get her head on straight and thank her lucky stars for Eddy boy….even though I grudgingly like Jacob.
Alice makes me smile and Edward is ESSENTIAL… He and Bella have to stay together.
So, pretending that it’s impossible for Edward and Alice to die, then I guess it will be Rosalie.
oops, I read over mine after I posted it. The Cullens find out that the Volturi want to get rid of the werewolves, not that the Cullen’s themselves want to get rid of the werewolves
well I think there are many possibles of different deaths in breaking dawn even though we all want or don’t want it to happen. We all pretty much know that Jacob haters want Jacob to die and people that don’t want anyone to die thinks that Charlie will die. My opinion is I think Billy is going to somehow die. I don’t know how but he will. Then the pact will decide not to tell Jacob because it will make him more depressed and by accident someone from the pact will think about it while in ‘werewolf form’. Jacob will come back, mad. He will try to get back Bella, the one person in his life he loves that he might just lose. Which sounds really sweet but I hope Jacob dies too because I’m totally Team Edward!
haha.
I think Sam’s is going to die, because then Jacob will HAVE to come back and be the alpha. It just would make sense if you think about it! And then Solomon will get his dramatic death scene in the Breaking Dawn movie he wants so much!! lol
Thanks,
ZOE
I think that Carlisle will die.
Here’s why:
I think the Volturi crash the wedding. And they are like pissed that Bella’s still human. So they try to kill Bella right then and there at the wedding
The Cullens [and Tanya’s family cause they are at the wedding too] join forces and FIGHT the Volturi. And then someone of the Volturi kills Carlisle. So Carlisle dies (sobs) and then someone else is attacking Edward and so he is distracted, and then Bella gets seriously hurt like “crushed”. The only way to save Bella is to change her into a vampire. With Carlisle dead, Edward has to change Bella right then and there.
So thats my theroy. I don’t want Carlisle to die, but if Bella gets hurt that the only way to save her is to make her into a vampire, I think Stephenie would have Edward change her. And Edward might stop at the last minute and have Carlisle change her, but if Carlisle is dead then Edward HAS to change her. =/
I’m not really sure but I say Jane. I think she will hurt Bella and because of that will she get in a fight with Edward or Jacob, (or the other way around) and she dies like Victoria did or something to that extent. But if you want to go with a more human death I think Billy will be pushin’ dasies. The old fellow has so much to deal with that he’ll just pass peacefully or like Harry Clearwater did. But thats how I feel.
I hope Edward dies. or Bella. Either one would be fine by me. lol jkjk
But I am pretty sure Sam will die because of the same reason that everyone else has come up with. I also think that Seth might die because I’m pretty sure he will start to become a beloved character in Breaking Dawn, Not the Favorite, but he will be a sad death. And I realllyy Realllyy reallly hope Jake does not die. The reason I think that he WON’T die is because i think steph will want to write more stories about him *crosses fingers* I really don’t want to read Midnight Sun but I will probably end up reading it anyways.
I always thought that this would be hysterical, obviously i have a crude sense of humor…….
What if Bella and Edward finally marry and Edward is about to bite Bella BUT there is a HUMONGOOOO plot twist and Edward says “Bella, I never loved you. It was all a joke.!!! MUAHAHH HAH AHHH”
and then he kills her. hahah that would be sooo comical
The thing is that it can be anyone. It’s like with the Breaking Dawn book cover, everyone had their own ideas of what it would be, but it ended up that we were way off. To me, I don’t know who will die but it seems like it’ll be shocking or unexpected. Stephenie Meyer said in an interview that two books inspired her while writing Breaking Dawn, which was one A Midsummer’s Night’s Dream and the other was not said. That other book was not said maybe that it would give something out. What ever that other book may be, can possibly connect with the whole who will die. I definitely don’t want it to be like Tristian and Isolde or Tucl Everlasting. because tht would give off that maybe Edward or Bella might die. I really don’t want thaqt to happen. All I’m saying is that that other book that inspired Stephenie to write Breaking Dawn can possibly tell who died and who ever does or doesn’t will be a complete shocker.
I think Jacob might die because yesterday me and a bunch of people were talking about breaking dawn and theories and how me and my friend got every single prediction wrong in chapter one. That’s really pathetic eh? but anyways we started talking about the prefice and what we thought was going on when the idea came to me. We know some of the book is not going to be in Bellas perspective so what if the prefice is Jacob talking. He almost got killed by a vampire before maybe the other near death experiences werent just physical but emotinal again with losing Bella. its a long shot and i really hope it doesnt happen but with stephanie you never know
I know this may upset some people but this is my answer to the question i think one of the cullens is going to die i think this because there some fight is going to happen before bella is a vampire and there protecting her so i think one cullen will die protecting bella so i think every one will be really sad over the loss and then someone will attack and there will be a big battle
Id think all couples might be at risk there. We’ve all seen how much they care about each other. And I might think either Emmet, Jacob or Edward will risk their lives to save the ones they love.
In the case of Jake, we know he is very stubborn, so he might try to risk his life in order to save Bella. As might Edward, but since I love him best, I dont want him to go.
In Emmet’s case, if Rosalie is ever at danger (which can be least probable, but, who knows, Stephenie might give us a shocker!) he might save her life as well as she did when he was attacked by a bear.
I would hate to see any of the Cullen’s die at Breaking Dawn, but such is life. If they all survive, it will be great. But love might put their lifes on the line or just risk their lives trying to be hero (which Jake might do).
Lots of love from an avid Twilight fan from Costa Rica!
Okay.
I really think that more than one person will die.
Who?
Um…
first: Rosealie. Just because of the bond that they have over the last three books. They way she was always mad at her and ingoring her. But then in the third she came around a little and told Bella about her story and why Bella shouldn’t become a vampie. But I think she will die saving Bella some how. And then that would bring me to my theorie. But it would have to do with a big fight and it will be a life and death situation. She will take her to Carlisle and all that.
Second: I really think that Sam will die trying to protect Bella from something. Like Bella would be hurt and then other Vampies are attacking and he would be procteing her and he relaxs for a split second and something hurts him and he can’t heal fast enough so he dies over Bella Procting her from what ever is coming. Then Jacob will be the hero and get her to The Cullens.
Third: I think Jacob will die in the end of the book. About what i don’t know. But I think he willl come to the end of the wedding for a second and see that Bella is happy about what she chose and then something bad happens.
Okay those are the people I think will die. I don’t think all three of them will die just if someone does die it might be those. But I have a really bad feeling that Bella or Edward will die.
NOT SOMETHING I WANT!
but something that might happen.
But Stephenie will lose some people but I am just saying it is a feeling that I don’t want to come ture!
Ok. If you have read the first chapter of Breaking Dawn then you know that Seth really plays a role now in the story. Sure he was there before but now he is closer to Bella and Edward. So I think that Stephenie is bringing him into the story to take him out.
If you remember in Eclipse he was soo eager to join in the fight at the end and was very upset when he had to stay behind. Even though that was a bit ironic as we already know.
But anyway I think that now he would be even more eager for a fight because he wants to protect Bella AND edward. He really likes them or at least that’s what I got from the first chapter.
I think that Seth will die trying to protect the Cullens (including Bella) even if they don’t need it he will want to help. I also think that it will set the werewolves and vampires back again. They have an alliance now but I think there will be something to happen that will mess it up. And I think that this will be it.
I could go on and on about that little fact but I don’t want to because that wasn’t the question. =]
(By the way: Who else is reminded of a tiny little family with Seth, Edward, and Bella? Seth just sooo reminds me of the little brother type. Like Bella’s little brother or something. I love him to death!!!! Well, maybe I shouldn’t have worded that this way)
First of all I dont think anyone of the cullens will die, because they are all virtually indistructable. Alice and Edward knows every move an attacker would make, Emmett is so strong, and Carlisle is so entelligent and experienced. Rosalie and Esme I think would be able to handle themselves too. If they needed help, their spouses would surely help them. Of course, I hope Bella dies by becoming a vampire. I cant stand the thought of Bella and Edward not being able to spend eternity together. I think one of the were wolves will die (at least one) probably Leah or Jacob. I could deffinitely see Jacob dying. He would give his life up for Bella, after she gets herself in trouble.
(p.s. YOU ALL ROCK!!! and iʻd like to send a haller out to all the other guy twilight fans)
I honestly hope she doesn’t kill anyone but that would be unlikely, just as long as she doesn’t pull a jk rowlling on us (you know killing a major character that we all fell in love with like dumbledore in the hp series) Given we would all get over it but still I want immunity for Bella, Edward, Alice, Carlisle or Jake, sorry to all Jacob haters but I don’t want him killed.
With that said I think it can truly be any of the supporting characters, She could kill any of the minor characters and the story could still go on for possible futures books. but if she dares to kill any of the immune ppl I would personally start an official twilight series book burning!!!
Well, I think that Sam or Seth will die. Sam in order to get Jacob back and Seth because the Volturi don’t like him and Edward being buddies.
I also think that a Cullen will die (I hope I’m wrong about this). My guess is it will be Rose. During the fight with the Volturi Rose is left to protect human Bella while the others fight. They are found by Jane who uses her power to try to get Rose away from Bella, but she won’t budge. Bella distracts Jane with the smell of blood (she cut herself) and Rose is able to try to kill her. That’s when Alec shows up and attacks Rose. Just as Rose is finished off [:(( sobs ] Emmett Alice and Edward show up, (Alice had a vision). Jane had already bitten Bella and it’s to late to suck out the venom this time. KABAM Bella’s a vamp!!!
Only Stephenie knows what’s really gonna happen though……
I am no Jacob hater (unlike some people, ahem, ahem), but I think JACOB will die, because the way I see it, there are only three options for him.
OPTION ONE: Jacob Imprints on an amazing girl (that he hasn’t already met since his first phase). I don’t think option one is possible. From a story-telling standpoint, Stephenie Meyer has not introduced to us (the reader) an eligible match for Jacob yet. I know, I know, many people are are hoping for Jacob to imprint on Angela, but we barely know Angela. She’s such a minor character. How can she be a good match for Jacob when we don’t even know her? There are so many readers who love and care about Jacob (myself included, although I’m Team Edward), that in order for us to be pleased and convinced that he’s happy, the girl he ends up with has to be someone we (the readers and Jacob-lovers) completely love. I don’t think there’s enough time in Breaking Dawn to introduce a character good enough for Jacob that will satiate the Jacob-lovers. I personally couldn’t see Jacob settling for just any girl (including Angela). She’s got to be an amazing girl, and if there was such a girl, I think we would already know about her.
OPTION TWO: Jacob pines for Bella his whole, long, werewolf life. I can’t think of anything more depressing than this. I would rather he were put out of his misery than always long for Bella. This leads us to…
OPTION THREE: Jacob dies. Personally, I would rather Jacob die, than suffer his whole life from a broken heart. I love him too much (but again, I’m Team Edward) to see him suffer. I think as a reader, my love for Jacob would be sealed if he gave his life protecting Bella.
I think option one is the “happily ever after” that we’d all like, but I’m not entirely convinced that Stephenie Meyer will deliver that to us (although, she might, based on how she ended “The Host”). Option two is my least favorite, and option three is the most bold and noble, although sad, in my opinion.
nice theory. i hope you are wrong mainly because i want bella changed by edward and no one else. i will miss rose if she dies, but anyone else would be devistating. if it were carlisle i would mourn for months.
I think that Billy will die. Forcing Jake to come back. This will happen like, right before the wedding. Bella will go to his Wedding to pay her respects. Edward being unalowed in La Push won’t be able to go. Bella will see Jake and can’t help but feel an overwelming sence of love for him. So she runs off with him (also out of fear of becomming a vampire…). Alice see’s her desicion to run off but doesn’t stop her beause it is what Bella really wants. When she is with Jacob the Volturi goes looking for her. But cannot find her. Their powers are very limited when it comes to Bella and since they know nothing about Jake they can’t count him in their efforts. Thus Bella is safe from the volturi.
There are many reasons for my claim.
Number 1: I have this overwellming sence that Bella does not become a vampire.
Number 2: If yuo got the special edition of Eclipse you got the poster and I don’t think that she would have to tell Edward that they belong together.
Number 3: It could happen, you have to admit it.
reasons my claim doesn’t work:
Number 1: What wuold Edward do???