Team Edward or Team Jacob?

Jul 9th, 2008 | By | Category: Book News

ew.gif 

Entertainment Weekly has an article on the Edward/Jacob debate here!

78 Comments to “Team Edward or Team Jacob?”

  1. Cora-Ann says:

    TEAM JACOB ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Isee why everybody likes Edward, but come on he’s really boring except for the part where he’s a vampire. BUT JAke is so HOTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!HE can be funny and sweet and passionate ynlike edward who overprotective and annoying.I thought there were so many team edward people k=now i find out so much people who are Team Jacob..So yeah GO TEAM JACOB

  2. sabrina says:

    jacob only fix’s cars and talk on the beach and ya’ll find that fun really what have he done that ya’ll find fun really?
    and if edward didn’t keep saving bella there would have only been one book.
    and how many times have jacob save bella besides that one time?
    and he only left bella cause he thought she would be better off and when she was with jacob only guy she thought about was edward and that’s a good thing he keep her away from jacob he sucks
    and there’s more team cool edward than you know if you go on another website you’ll see
    always with team edward team vampire
    the werewolfs suck there boring and really they should join team vampire we all know they want too

  3. Jacob 1 fan says:

    Team Jacob ALL the way! Yeah, Edward this Edward that, but Jacob’s personality is allways better.
    Plus, he doesn’t suck blood. and that my friend is always a plus.

  4. Jacob 1 fan says:

    plus who likes mking out with a rock?

  5. sabrina says:

    and who like kissing a dog yuck nasty
    all i have to say is i’m edward number one fan all you have to say about jacob is how he has a great personality and to tell you the truth he don’t have a personality he just want to work on cars and walk on the beach
    and just in case you forgot that bella ends up with edward the best one in the book so take that jacob fans
    oh and if your soooo in love with jacob you could always take him he sucks
    soooo yeah it will always be edward this and edward that
    and that’s the way it will be

  6. sabrina says:

    oh and plz tell me the truth what do ya’ll like about jacob sooo much he’s boring really boring

  7. teamjacob says:

    whats not to like…werewolves are waaaaaaaaaay sexier than stupid vampires. plus i think bellas stupid and idiodic, but i dont really care if she chose edward. i want jacob all for myself.

  8. sabrina says:

    and all the jacob fans can fight over him
    werewolves sucks there’s no way there sexier
    beside on the movie the one that plays jacob is cute that it nothing more
    and the one that plays edward is sexy no duh
    seems once again no one told me why beside how in your eyes there hot
    plz tell me i want to know jacob fans i really want to know
    i know your great people cause your twilight fans but come on jacob is not the best

    edward all the way
    p.s
    and it seems like i’m the only one that has to tell you how better edward is not that it will change who you like it don’t matter just stay a twilight fan

  9. Ann says:

    TEAM JACOb! – but only because I want EDWARD all for myself, lol.

  10. Team Jake!! :D says:

    Come on,
    Jake is soo much cooler! He cares for everyone!
    Edward is just an overprotective ROCK!
    Jake has sooo much more personality!
    I don’t care who Bella wants, I’ve always really disliked her (she wines alot and is way too clingy)
    I want the hot WEREWOLF!
    Jake is funny, a fighter, and he has his flaws (unlike Edward-really-boring-perfect-guy)
    GO TEAM JACOB!!!!!!!
    😀

  11. Kerli says:

    ok, i’m sorry, but TEAM JACOB!!

  12. Kerli says:

    in Twilight, i liked Edward. I, like Bella, thought he was amazing.
    i liked Edward better in New Moon too. i mean, Jacob was awesome until in turned into a werewolf and became a jerk.
    but by Eclipse, i was SO BORED with Edward. he is the same thing over and over and over. he has really NO PERSONALITY! I wanted Bella to get with Jacob. But i knew she wouldn’t.
    i keep thinking of that part in Eclipse— “He’s like a drug for you, Bella.” Jacob said. “I see that you can’t live without him now. But I would have been healthier for you. Not a drug; I would have been the air, the sun.”
    which is SO TRUE!!!
    that’s ok, Bella and Edward belong together.
    i’ll take Jake.
    TEAM JAKE!!!

  13. Anna Russel says:

    First of all, I think this is completely hilarious how we all get so into nonliving characters!!!
    Still, I am EXTREMELY into it myself!!!!!
    And I would just like to say…

    TEAM JACOB ALL THE WAY!!!!

    I hated Edward from the beginning. He only paid any attention to Bella because of her smell. That’s a great basis for a relationship, don’t you think? Their relationship isn’t real–it’s more of an obsession. It has no depth. They fight with each other about their relationship and the circumstances surrounding it than actually having one! Edward doesn’t even seem to know Bella at all! And then Edward never does or says anything different or unexpected. He has no personality. He has no faults. Bella always felt that he was so superior to her. A relationship shouldn’t be like that–it should be mutual, you should feel equal! I agree with Kerli on the Jacob quote. “He’s like a drug for you, Bella.” Jacob said. “I see that you can’t live without him now. But I would have been healthier for you. Not a drug; I would have been the air, the sun.” That is so right!! Another thing that someone mentioned above, Edward never once made Bella laugh. Not once. A recent poll showed that the ability to laugh together is the number one reason to choose a partner. Hello? Edward or Jacob? PLUS, Edward STALKS Bella. He lets her have no friends, no social life, not even see her best friend. He never lets her take chances, explore who she is. It’s ridiculous. And then he just up and abandons her. Don’t tell me that he thought it was for her own good, I know he did. But seriously, if you are that in love with someone you are not going to be able to just up and leave, especially when you KNOW it has to hurt her in some way!! Jacob would never DREAM of hurting Bella like that!! Jacob is hilarious, has so much personality, and truly loves Bella, not in the obsessive-i-have-to-know-where-you-are-every-second-of-the-freaking-day way. He let’s her take risks and do crazy things, but he’s always there to protect and save her if she needs it. Heck, he abandoned his own wolf pack for her! And yet he still knew from the beginning, and it especially showed when he gave her the bracelet, that he was going to lose. But he still tried! My favorite line from the whole series was when Jacob said (paraphrasing) “As long as your heart keeps beating, I’ll be here, fighting for you.”

    Be honest…would you guys read the series if Jacob wasn’t there? No. It would be a boring and totally predictable story that no one would read.

    Actually, I don’t think Bella deserves EITHER of them! She’s a crabby, self-centered, idiotic, unrealistic drama queen.

    Having said ALL of that, I know how the series ends, I know what happens, but this is just my opinion on the subject!!

  14. Anna Russel says:

    But the main important thing is WE ALL LOVE TWILIGHT!!!!

  15. sabrina says:

    i don’t like bella myself she is stupid and i never said i liked bella i said team vampire team edward but still all ya’ll say about jacob is that he sooo cool he is not only thing he do is try and make her like him it’s sad really that he want to come in between two people that’s already dating
    i liked jacob in twilight because he was not really into her he was himself
    and jacob hurted her too so don’t make it like it was just edward cause it wasn’t
    and when jacob imprint on some one he leaves bella then what kind of story would that be and who would want a boyfriend that will leave you when he sees some one else
    and like i said before jacob’s in the books to put more chapters in there
    she went to edward sooo she picked who she wanted she picked him for a reason he is better
    really jacob is the boring one all he want to do is make her kiss him and date him
    i have nothing to say about jacob he is soooooo stupid i call him the chapter filler now
    i really don’t see what’s soooo interesting about him he is a dog you keep as a pet not a boyfriend
    and not once in that book did jacob to me say anything funny the funny one in the book is alice another favorite of mines
    and she could have just killed jacob off in the thrid book there was no use of him after that

    AND ALWAYS TEAM EDWARD TEAM VAMPIRE
    jacob and the rest of the dogs just need to be killed sucked dried by the vampires cause if she would have a fight down we all know how would have won……………*cough vampires cough*

  16. sabrina says:

    is sm wrote a fight down my bad

  17. kristen says:

    lmaoooo this is soo funny reading all of this.
    anyway, TEAM JACOB!

  18. Rosalie says:

    TEAM EDWAD ALL THE WAYYY!!! NEVER AM I EVER GONNA BE ON TWAM JACOB! I LOVE EDWARD!!!! 🙂

  19. Rosalie says:

    AGAIN I LOVE EDWARD AND TWILIGHT AND ITS KINDA WEIRD CAUSE I HAVE ROSALIE’S NAME!!!!!!! 😀

  20. Sara says:

    Okay, I am a total TEAM EDWARD fan. I had no idea that there were so many Team Jacob peeps, but if you’re happy with a dog who doesn’t respect bella, then more power to ya. He tricked her into kissing him in eclipse, and that just sunk his ship in my book. I like him, as Bella’s friend, and MAYBE as a person, but not as a match for bella. He was WAY more cool in twilight, when he was only around for like, ten pages. And in the first half of New Moon, before he was a wolf and became an ass. I just think he’s really selfish, and was always interfering with bella and edward’s relationship, making it awkward. He should just want bell to be happy. And for those ‘team jakes’ who say jacob would never leave her, he would. He’d leave her if he imprinted, and he’d leave her for his pack. He DID leave her in eclipse, and would rather trick her into kissing him and then run off rather than staying with her. He’d rather fight with his pack than be with her and keep her safe. Jake is OK. But not more than a best friend and a shoulder to cry on. Oh, and for those who think jake is bells’ ‘soulmate’, if they were meant for each other, wouldn’t have he imprinted on her?

    Now, Edward. I think he’s the best. He’s smart, sweet, considerate, and a total gentleman. Plus, he does have a sense of humor. The movie made him look more awkward, when I saw him as very confident. I mean, if he wasn’t so confident that bella was his, than he’d have knocked Jake off the face of the planet like he should’ve. But he kept bella’s feelings in mind. And if you think Edward is over-protective, don’t you think he has reason to? How many times has bella nearly died? He even tried to separate himself from her for her own good. Plus, I’d like a guy who cared enough for me to want to keep me safe. I found myself laughing when he disabled her car though. That was funny. Anyways, I know Edward isn’t perfect. But he’s really nice. He means well, and he’s modest. He doesn’t really ask for anything from bella, and doesn’t force her to love him. He just knows that he loves her. And he is meant for bella.

    Bella is…hm. I liked her in twilight, but in new moon, she was a total drama queen. In eclipse, she was an obsessive, and a bit spazzy. Breaking dawn was ok. She worries too much. I liked her a lot in Twilight, cause she was curious, cynical, sarcastic and perceptive-traits that are sometimes used to describe myself. But edward loves bella despite her freaking out half the time. And that’s cool. Bella is half in half right now. Eh. She’s ok.

  21. Ashley says:

    definitely team EDWARD! jacob is ignorant and honesly i don’t think he knows how to treat a girl. he always says the rudest things and gets bella upset. who would want to be upset every 5 minutes because of something someone said? i wouldn’t. edward is nice, caring, loving, and would do anything in the world for bella. seriously, what’s so wrong with that?! he may be perfect, but that doesn’t mean he’s boring and has no personality! and jacob imprinting on renesmee? if you guys think edward was obsessed with bella, what do you call jacob? it’s almost like he HAS to be apart of her life somehow and he chooses to do this through imprinting on her daughter.. how ridiculous?! yeah i’d be pissed too. anyways, team edward all the way baby! <3333

  22. Miranda says:

    TEAM EDWARD!
    bella and edward are ment to be together and even the jacob fans know it.
    im not saying i hate jacob, i swear.
    i actually really love jacob, he’s smart, caring, kind, and loves bella. but if i had to chose which character l would want bella to choose, i would have to go with edward.
    bella loves jacob, but her love for edward is WAY stronger. she even thought that when her and jake were kissing,
    she thought, this is just going to be harder for us both because i know who i cant live without.
    and you jake fans, he ends up happy with Nessie!
    so everyone wins in the end.

    sorry Jake fans, but did you read any of the books?!
    cant you tell that her love for edward is more powerful than any love that will ever happen to bella?
    i mean, common!
    you had to have a clue that when jake didnt imprint on bella that they werent ment to be together!
    that should have been the tip off right there!
    he didnt imprint on her, so one day he would and then bella would be happy with edward,
    and jake would be happy with the person that he imprints on!

    did you really not see that comming?

    edward+bella= love that POWERS OVER soulmate

    jake+bella= love that would be a weak, faint echo of the love that bella has experienced.

    jake+nessie=love that POWERS OVER soulmate

    everyone ends up happy:)

  23. Miranda says:

    team jake fans,
    please explain what made you start liking jake over edward?
    seriously cause im interested, and i want to know what made you change your mind.

    (cause we were all team edward fans in the begining, duh, cause there was no jake, besides those ten pages, really)

    TEAM EDWARD!:)

  24. Cathy says:

    EDWARD DOES HAVE A PERSONALITY!
    his personality is old fashioned, and so is bellas,
    making them the perfect match:)
    jake is ok, but just like Miranda said, he didnt imprint on her for a reason, because they werent ment to be in the first place.

  25. kailey says:

    TEAM EDWARD!

    Theres no way she wouldn’t pick Edward! He’s so caring and amazing and he’d do anything for Bella! Jacob is more fitting as her best friend rather than her boyfriend. Edward is her soul mate and she can’t live without him. I hate it when Jacob tries to get in the way of Edward and Bella’s relationship. I wish sometimes that Edward wouldn’t be so calm and would fight for Bella, but he never will because it could hurt her if he hurt Jacob. Which shows that Edward cares about Bella way more than Jacob does. Jacob didn’t even imprint on her- thank god! I liked it better before Jacob was a wolf and only wanted to be her friend, which is the way things should be. Jacobs not her true love. He was just there as a friend to heal her broken heart after Edward had to leave her in New Moon, which was for her own good he thought. Jacob could never heal the broken emptiness Bella felt after Edward left. Even when he was gone when she was with Jacob she was just using him to make her feel happier without her true love. She did the reckless things like riding a motorcycle just so she could hear Edward’s voice, and the only way she could have that was to spend time with Jacob an do stupid things. Jacob will never be enough for her. Her life would be miserable without Edward, and she loves him much more than she does Jacob. I would rather see Bella with Mike than with Jacob! You can plainly see that she’s happiest with Edward. Jacob is awful and he’s always manipulating Bella to kiss him and then she just end’s up getting hurt. Edward would never try to hurt her and is always protecting her and being incredibly selfless. TEAM EDWARD ALL THE WAY!

  26. Rumer says:

    Team Jacob!!!All the way man! Taylor is way too cute^^

  27. KATRIENA says:

    WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE….?
    TEAM JACOB ALL THE WAY……!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  28. LOL says:

    LOL, oh c’mon people, i feeling puke that Jaocb imprints on Renesmee? LOL. no point debating, bella has chosen edward over jacob. though both are really nice, edward is the kind of guy most girls might want but jacob has a personality that cheers people up or wad.

Leave a Comment