What Belongs in the Movie Twilight?
Oct 4th, 2008 | By Kallieross | Category: Featured Articles, Question of the Week
This week we want to know two things…
1. What do you think HAS to make it from the book to the movie?
2. What can you live without?
-
Ads & Sponsors
-
Books
Ads & Sponsors
Browse Archives
December 2014 November 2014 June 2014 February 2014 January 2014 November 2013 October 2013 August 2013 July 2013 June 2013 May 2013 April 2013 March 2013 February 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009 February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008 August 2008 July 2008 June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008Search Archives
Hey gals:)
1. They have to have the scene where Edward is “messing” with Bella’s mind before the go out to the clearing to play baseball. Where he is trying to get her to to ride on his back again.
2. I could do without alot of the scenes where the Cullens aren’t in school due to it being sunny outside.
I love pretty every scene in Twilight but I’ll be flexible! I want the movie sooo badly!!!!!!
the scene I could live without in the movie is when Bella get’s dropped off at the airport by her mom.
Jazz (Team Edward,Bella,Renesme!)
1. What do you think HAS to make it from the book to the movie?
I think the whole part with Edward ‘crying’ over Bella being unconcious from James needs to be added. The romance in that whole chapter makes my heart swell every time. Also, the phone call from Edward to Bella when she’s away with Jasper and Alice. That’s a fantastic part.
2. What can you live without?
I find pretty much every part of the book important, but if I had to choose…it would probably be when Jacob shows up at the prom. I don’t care too much. Just when Edward is angry about how Jacob called Bella pretty.
Whoops! I misread the second questioin.(Mine was number 11)
I definatly could live without….I really don’t know. I just sat here for like twenty minuets thinking and I really couldn’t think of anything I wouldn’t mind if it wasn’t in the movie. I just want all of it!
1.Totally the Port Angeles part. Im pretty sure it will be in the movie but if it isn’t then that will be a mistake not putting it in. Edward tells Bella he’s a vampire, so that is an important scene.
2. I could live without jacob, nahh im just kiddin, i love jacob (but not as much as edward!) I could live without the part where jacob comes to the prom and tells bella all that crap, but I love it when edward is mad that jacob only called her pretty. I love every part of the book, but that part was frustrating!!!!!!!!
1. I can’t live without the first time Edward says “I love you” to Bella, and it has to been at the right time and place. If you have forgotten it was when Edward and Bella were on there way to the baseball field.
2. I could live without Jacob.
1. HAVE to include james being destroyed-it is the bestest bit in the book!! play up the action and violence!!
2. can live without an overshow of soppy or corny scenes!! seriously if the movie is corny i will never read any of the books again!! the action/fantasy bits are so WAY the best bits in the book!! tho i really really hate robert pattinson-so play up jacobs role!! lol!
Hey Girls!!
1. The Meadow and ballet scene are very important to me. I know they are in the movie already, but I hope the actors and the Writers did their best to potray these critical scences. I want to see a lot of emotion and intensity in both these scenes. Prom is another scene I have to see. Hopefully Kristin can act like Bella did showing the shock of having to dance infront of people. Any Bella and Edward scene should not be cut.
2. I think the airport scne could go (as long as people know why she came to Forks in the First place).
Okay, so i have heard so many people say things like, “Its not going to be true to the book!” and “Oh my gosh why would they make a movie, they are just going to let us all down.” but heres my quick take on all this, I think that all the little changes, and new little bonuses are going to make and amazing story even better, I think that with a story like this where you can expand on so much, it would be terrible for them not to branch out and extend a little.
I really want to see James hunting just an innocent bystander, i know that sounds kinda twisted, but you never get a sense of how much of a threat he is until the ballet studio scene, so i think it would make things… more intense. And for some reason i think this film will be a little different, because it will probably still be told from Bellas’ perspective, but then there are all the add ins from Edwards side, like when he is alone with Emmett and he says “This is wrong Edward, she’s not one of us” so i don’t think it will be mainly from her side so some people might eat that up, while others will get mad. I’m so excited for this movie, and i get all bubbly everytime i watch the trailers! AHH can’t wait 🙂
THE KISS!!! DUH! That’s all. If that’s not in there I will be writing so many nasty hate letters to Summit, my hand will fall off!
I can do without them making up extra scenes for jacob. He really should get no more than 10 min of screen time.
ok without some scenes the movie would be a disaster .
1) first kiss
2)second kiss were she faints
3) bella being stalked and edward saving her
4)the questions about vampires and humans
5)the dinner
6) the meadow
7)the phone call (cry)
8)and when edward is screaming bellas name and begging for her not to die!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love that
there the scenes that make twilight, twilight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
One part that should make it to the movie from the book, is of course the whole meadow scene, and the part after the meadow when they are back at the truck. Another scene that belongs in the movie is the part right before Edward and Bella go to the field to play baseball. I love how he talks to her and how he just “dazzles” her. One scene I would like to see in the movie, but could live without is where he saves Bella from the group of guys in Port Angeles. I have other parts but they all come from the other books. I’m so excited about the movie!! I Know I wont be disappointed!! I can’t wait for it to come out!!!!
Hey,
I’m Sirley from Estonia 🙂 First of all I love your podcast…yours and Imprint are my favourite 🙂
1) I really would like to see Eric-Mike-Tyler asking Bella to the prom, and her being annoyed with it, and also this would include the Port Angeles shopping scene where Bella discovers what Tyler has been telling everybody and the exchange between Bella and Edward when she tells him in the car that she’d like to run over Tyler so he wouldn’t feel guilty….lol. That would be great comic relief.
2) Its hard to say what I could live without…as I wouldn’t mind having everything in the movie 🙂 But if I’d have to choose then most probably when Bella’s reading or writing to Renee. It’s not that I would have anything against those scenes, but I wouldn’t particularly miss them.
Keep up the great work!
Hey Girls,
Oh my goodness this a tough question! Ok first of all like everyone else I want the meadows scene and the first kiss and Edward watching her sleep. Also I want to see her meeting the whole family and Bella hearing Carlisle’s story. And I cannot do without of course is the phone call from James and her being in the hotel room with Jasper and Alice. I also thought it would be cool to see Alice’s visions. The things I could live without are a bit trickier. I dont really like the airport thing that much. I could also do without the blood typing because I don’t really like the idea of Bella being carried around. Also I don’t like the idea of the evil vampires getting their next meal it gives me the willies chillies! Um sorry to the violent people who watch this awesome podcast I don’t like the idea of watching James being torn apart. I think over all it will be an awesome movie. I love your podcast and try to answer the question of the week the best I can every time!
The one part of the movie I want to see is where Bella goes on the internet to seach about Vampires after going to First Beach and Jacobs “scary stories”. I know it’s not as great as the meadow scene or the other important ones, but I find that this scene in the book was sort of a life changing one for Bella, where she finally knows what Edward is, and doesn’t care because she is so in love with him already that she accepts him for who he is. I think it would show more depth for her character and if they throw in voice overs, where Bella narrates, I would like that. I do like that they are adding scenes like the flashback, alought it was not really part of the book, I think it will really add to the story telling of the film. Now, a scene that I could live without in the movie…hard to choose one because all the scenes are so good in the book. I would like the time where Edward is gone to be really short. He needs as much sceen time as possible. It could be something along the lines and where he leaves on that first day, and then the next scene it’s been a week and he has fianlly returned, something quick so it can get to the good stuff. Other then that, I wouldn’t want anything to be left out, but we can’t always get what we want sometimes. Love the Podcast!
Hey girls,
First time listener and i must say that you girls are GRRRREAT!!! So to answer the questions…
1: I agree with the most of what everyone else is saying, the meadow scene, Port Angeles, the first kiss, etc… but something that i don’t think i’ve seen anyone else mention, that i would think would be really cool to see, is the part of the book where it had snowed and the Cullen kids were in the cafeteria and Bella notices them goofing off and Emmett flicking the water out of his hair at the rest of his family. I thought that this was a really cute endearing scene because you see the love they possess for each other and you get to see the “teenager” side of the Cullens, even though they were really just trying to act “normal”. And also the other scene i would LOVE to see is after Edward says the “hair looks like a haystack” comment, when he suggests it time for breakfast and then Bella grabs her neck in terror and shock and scares Edward and then he has to clarify that it’s time for breakfast for the HUMAN!!! I could not stop laughing at this part of the book!!! Tooo Funny!!!
2: The part that doesn’t really need to be there is probably when Edward watches Bella as she’s pulling out of her parking spot and almost rams into one of the kids trying to drive off and then Edward laughs… kind of unnecessary i think. Plenty of other ways to show Bella’s clumsiness.
First i’d like to say hi from London! Thanks for such a great podcast i really think you guys do a wonderful job.
I think that the scene where Bella meets the Cullen family in their home is incredibly important, although it is not so much an emotional scene e.g. Bella and Edward in hospital or the meadow, it is really the formal introduction of the Cullens as a family as well as individuals. I find this scene in the book gave me my first impressions of each character because of how they behave towards Bella e.g Alice dashing towards her in excitement, Jasper keeping his distance. I think in the movie it will be even more important and revealing because facial expressions and body language is even more expressive in this circumstance than writing. Also, i think it will really show how amazing the casting is when the actors can really portray their characters without much dialogue.
The scenes I think the movie could do without is probably the “thinking” time Bella has to herself about her impressions of Forks, Charlie, her human friends and her truck. Its not because i think they are unimportant, but rather that seeing them and/or their actions with Bella interaction with them throughout is enough to get and idea of what Bella thinks, thus giving the movie enough time and more to show interaction and action scenes!
Hope you like my first answer to question of the week!
i want to see the scene when they r in the resturant after he just saved her from the creepy guys and the waitress it trying to get Edwards attention.
oh and when edwards watches bellas sleep
oh and the medow scenes
🙂
1. The scenes i cant live without are : Port Angeles and the meadow scene as this was where there relationship really progressed also when Bella met the cullens for the first time
2. I really would’nt care if they cut Jacob out of all the movies (except Breaking Dawn of course) !
~Kirsty
So we all know from pictures and trailer that alot of the big parts are in it (baceball, medow, science class, ect…) I am very interested in seeing when bella first meets the Cullens and when she first sees the cullens house. I am very interested in how the house looks and especialy edwards room, i hope they have the little details like his music collection and system. Also i hope they dont cut out when Bella Alice and Jasper are hideing out, i feel like that was the only time you really got a chance to get to know Alice and Jasper in this movie.
as for what I dont care about, thats hard i know there are alot of small stuff that wont be in the movie.
I have to say tho i am MOSTLY excited about seeing the new flashback footage they did witht he cullens. I think it will be nice to see more of them, as i always say i feel like the rest of the cullens were not really developed in the first book and I am happy that they will get some more screan time.
i could totally want the whole bioagy lab room seen because in my eyes it it super funny and how she thinks there is something wrong with her and i just love that part. also i love the part where they are in the airport and she wants to go to the bathroom and that scary phone call i totally want.
there is really no spefic part i could live without but if i could pick a part it would be some of the boarding conversations they have in the book where they have no part for the future
Okay, so for the Twilight movie, I have a few things that I think should be in the movie. The first one is, and I know a lot of people say this, is the scene in the meadow. The first reason is that there’s the specific line that they said there:
“And so the lion fell in love with the lamb.”
“What a stupid lamb.”
“What a sick, masochistic lion.”
=D Yup, we all know it. The second reason is that I want to see Edward sparkle in the sun ; ). Okay, so the second scene that I want in it is when Edward and Bella eat dinner in Port Angles and then the drive back to Forks, ’cause that’s when everything falls into place for Bella, and she fully understands what Edward is (but she isn’t scared) and what he could do. The third one is the prom scene with Jake passing on Billy’s message, and Bella dancing in a boot and a high heel! The fourth and final thing I want in there (trust me, I could have made this list wwwwwaaaayyyyy longer) is all the boys asking Bella to the dance XD. And plus I hope they have the humor that Stephenie Meyer put into the book in the movie. Okay, (I say okay too much) so if they didn’t have something in the movie I think I would want it to be ummmmm… I honestly can’t think of anything I want to have taken out of the movie that was in the book =P. Oh! Also, I want at the very end, when Bella isn’t around, to have Edward confess his love for a girl called Amelia. Muhahahahahaha!!!!! (Don’t worry, I already know I’m insane)
1. What do you think HAS to make it from the book to the movie?
I would love to see when Bella is runing out of the airport to go to her home to “save” her mother.
2. What can you live without?
Hard to answere. Maybe…I just dont know, to hard to pick something.
Hi girls, i love the show
For the part of the book that i cant live without being in the movie is the anticipation of their first kiss. when reading the book i was on ends trying to figure out when it was going to happen. when it FINALY happened after the meadow scene i wanted to scream! i texted my best friend who had already read the book and was like finaly they kissed!! the anticipaiton made the kiss so much more sweet and meaningful. (on a side note i really want setphanie to finish midnight sun that way i can read what was going thru Edwards mind when he finally decides to kiss bella, because she totally wasn’t ready for it.)
the part of the book that i could probably live with out is….. i dont know if i want any of it cut out even the little things like when the cullens were gone because of the sun and when she leaves her mom at the airport is important for the set up of Bella’s charachter and how much she is into Edward…. BUT if i had to choose i guessi could live with cutting the trip to La Push for the first time shorter and biology class where they do blood typing :-/
I would love to see the scene where Edward “tampers” with Bella’s memory so she won’t remember her reasons for not wanting to cling to his back while he ran to the Cullens’ baseball field. I think it is a funny scene and shows how “dazzling” Edward can be.
I could live without the scene where Bella is reading in her backyard and falls asleep. I don’t think that would be interesting to watch on the big screen.
1) The right chemistry between Edward and Bella
2) Rob Patt being Edward (Gah!)
Hey girls!
I really want to see the part of the book when Edward plays Bella’s lullaby because that is really when their relationship truely blooms, and they both know that they are meant for each other. Edward is a bit hesitant of showing his true feelings for Bella, so he rights a beautiful lullaby for her that sticks with them throughout the highs and lows of their relationship. Although Edward can be a moron sometimes, what he did right there was really a precious sincere thing to do. NoThat part made me choke up because it was so sweet. I would also like to see as much Jacob Black as possible. You can’t have enough Jacob, now can you Kassie? 🙂
Now I could live without the parts at the beginning of the book when Bella is waiting on every limb for Edward to come back into her life at school. It’s kinda pathetic, and I can’t stand it when Bella is so whiny and dependent like that. I also don’t want to see Bella moping around waiting to die in the hotel with Alice and Jasper that much on the big screen. It seems to go on forever and it wouldn’t be that interesting to watch 20 minutes of Bella watching T.V, with Alice and Jasper staring at her.
With all this in mind, YOU HAVE NO IDEA HOW EXCITED I AM TO SEE THIS AMAZING MOVIE!!!!
I’m incredibly hopeful to see the lunch scene between Edward and Bella when he takes her lemonade bottle cap. I know that part is in Midnight Sun, but I think it is soo sweet, and totally what Edward and Bella do to add to their relationship. I also think that it would give newcomers to the series a bit more insight to just how desperate, i guess is the word, that Edward is to be close to Bella, without hurting her at this stage in the story, yet still remaining innocent, and really, well, sweet, as i’ve said already.
The one part that I could really live without is the snootiness (yes, snooootiness) from Lauren/Jessica etc, on how Bella gets the best looking guy in the school (well, the best looking guy ever). Honestly, those two are -insert inappropriate words here- and deserve what they get. Jessica gets Mike (HA! *rofl* dunno why anyone would want that!) and Lauren gets a fake modeling deal/bad haircut. Face it, they had it coming.
I wish I could write more as to why i like these parts/don’t want to see them, but I’m running late and must be off! Totally love the podcast, can’t wait to here what you ladies have to say this week! btw, i’m completely and utterly jealous that you get to go to LA. Not cool. At all. *pouts*
But I still love you all!
1. I think my favorite line in the entire book was
“Do I dazzle you?”
“Frequently”
I just love that line, it so cute! 🙂
2. Although I think this part is hilarious, I think the part where Bella gets asked to the dance by Eric, Tyler, and Mike is unnecessary. I thought that was kind of excessive, especially if Eric is really going to be a Eric/Ben character and is going to be going out with Angela.
Love the podcast!!!
-Jamie
i don’t think i would ever be able to live without Edward saving Bella from the evil guys in port angles and then taking her to dinner. I think it was so cute how bella gave him her theory on what he is. If it’s gone i’ll cry ;-( thats when she falls in love with him (or relizes it any way)
I could so live without the snow day at the high school, as long the road is covered in ice the next day I’m good without it. Besides, all Bella does is look at Edward (it would be nice to look at Rob though) 😉
1. What do you think HAS to make it from the book to the movie?
The meadow scene definately has to make it from the book and the movie because that was the moment that pretty much sealed the deal between Edward and bella. I also thing that the trip to La Push (intereactions/ story between Jacob and Bella is vital.
2. What can you live without?
Even though the trip to La push is vital, i think they can do without the hiking to the tide pools and whatnot. They can also do without the blood typing scene as well. Its not too to the story. I mean, it is important to know the bella can’t be around the smell of blood, but they can incorporate that is so many different ways. The snow ball fights can be done without too. I mean, it is important to know that it was cold, and icy, therefore it can elude to the car crash scene, but it doesn’t have to drag on forever and ever.
Can’t live without:
1. Edward and bella’s first kiss (i want it to be as close as possible to the book)
2. Tyler/Mike/Eric asking her to the dance
3.the part near the end when Tyler still thinks he is taking Bella to prom, and is talking to Edward on the phone = ]
4. the “lion fell in love with the lamb” quote
I also want to see edward watching bella while she sleeps.
i think the blood typing would be hilarious to see haha just so i can see mike getting pissed off by edward. that would be cool, i would also like to see edward watching bella as she sleeps hahaha ” my precious” that just comes into my mind whenever i imagine that scene, but yea im sure it will be great, the director had a good reason for some scenes not to be in the movie. i wish they would have casted a Quil though.
Well there is no way I can even begin to start on the scenes, but you know what I really hate they’re not putting into the movie?? Rosalie and Jasper’s last name!! They’re Cullens in the movie not Hales!! That just bugs me…sorry if I’m just obsessing, but it bugs me…
1. If the lullaby and the meadow scene aren’t right then i’ll probably cry…SERIOUSLY! Thats like where it all began!
2. The whole awkward and annoying relationship with mike newton…NO ONE CARES! no one likes him! i mean i like mike whelch (spell check?) but I just don;t want them to waste any precious time on stuff no one really wantst to see.
1. “If I could dream at all, it would be of you. And I’m not ashamed of it.” That quote HAS to be in the movie!
2. I could live without Edward being a show-off in the meadow (running around, tearing a branch off a tree and throwing it, etc.). It seems out of place in such a romantic scene, but if they wanted to put it somewhere else, I’d be fine with that.
I LOVE your podcast!
I am interested in seeing the part in the Meadow as well. I feel that any and all interactions between Bella and Edward are extremely important, because that’s when you get to see what the entire book is about. The scence at the meadow is not only important to the story, but I really wanna see what Edwards skin will look like, and the kissing scene. Also, I can’t wait to see hospital scene.
Now, I feel they can cut out all parts when Edward isn’t in school and in Denali, and a good portion of when he is ignoring her after the van incident. It’s necessary in the book so we know what’s going on in Bella’s head but it will just be a waste of time in the movie. Unless they decide to give some of Edwards POV in the movie….i did hear an interiew in which Rob stated he read some of Midnight Sun to get a better perspective of where Edwards’ mind was in order to portray it better in the movie. That would be great. I know they didn’t do it, but it’s nice to dream.
1) Port Angeles has to make it in, after all it is a major turning point in the story. So it definately essential to the movie.
2) I could probably live without the little things bella does in between. Like making dinner for Charlie, pondering about Edward, etc. Those little things are not essential and probably wouldn’t play out well in the film anyways.
Okay let me just say one thing………. all the small details that the fans are looking for, SOME MAY GET CUT! Such as…. when Edward is suppost to chuckle after something Bella said,THAT may not be in there! BUT(!!!) everyone says it stays really close to the book…so those might be in there!
IF they don’t have an amazing baseball scene I will be so MAD! I might have to wrip someone to shreds!!!!!!
I think that the Bio. scences should be exactlly to the book!and the Meadow*AWWW*
I really can’t wait for the LaPush scenes! Not for Jacob but for Embry!The guy who is playing him is really CUTE!
I don’t rember where I heard this but…. I heard that Kristen had to like knee the camera man to make it look like she was beatting him up(aka Port Anglus). I just rembered that it was you(tst)!!!! Lol I’m so out of it today!
Lots of TwiLove,
<3`erin
Oh and I SOOOO don’t want to see Mike and the other guys ask Bella out…It is a waist of time when we should be getting more BASEBALL!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ok I Know I have alredy answered this one but for The Host,I think it is a great book I am 11 and have read all of the Twilight books and Now am Reading The Host!Kalie I know you don’t like Sci Fi but this book is awesome!Ok for the Twilight movie being rated pg13 my parents saw the whole sensuality thing and were like your ad has to watch this first.Ok now 4 the questions.
1.)The Pot Angeles scene needs to stay,I would like to ee the lunch seen when Edward is like Why Don’t You sit with me today,Obviously the kisses,and The fight scene,Oh and of course when alice comes into the room nd was like I thought you were having her for dinner to Edward.Oh and when mike asks bella out
2.)I don’t think that we need to see Renee dropping Bella off at the airport,or all of the scenes where Billy Comes to warn Bella about the Cullens,the scene when Charlie comes running to the ambulane I don’t think needs to be in the movie either or seeing Jacob at Prom!!
Thanks for doing the Podcast you guys are great!!
Madison
Hi, all,
I’m certain all the major scenes will be included, so I know I won’t be disappointed about that. I think the part that will be hardest for the movie is to express the thoughts of the characters and capture their essence. In the book, it’s so much easier to write the thoughts of the characters to fill us in, but how will that be expressed in the movie? Do we have to just figure it all out from their facial expressions?
If the characters in the movie can convey the emotions expressed in the book, then they will have me at the first scene. If they’re fairly true to the book, include the major scenes, and anything they add is in line with what the “real” characters would do, the movie will be a major triumph. I hope they didn’t take too many liberties with Stephenie’s characters to embellish with what they think will dazzle a movie audience.
– Hoppie
I love the ya’lls podcast!!
1. What definitely has to make it into the movie is: The whole car ride conversation after the dinner in port angeles. it is such a pivotal scene. Even for the characters it is an all or nothing scene. They are basically laying it on the line–you can cut the tension with a knife. This is where Edward and Bella’s relationship takes a whole new twist, so it definitely needs to make into the movie. It fives an insights to the non-readers, also.
2. I can live without Renee’s scenes. Like I know that she’s the mom and all, but it is basically parts that I skip when I re-read. They can mention her, but all we need is the airport scene, and I think we are good. Like the e-mails, phone calls, and the very beginning in Phoenix can go.
Thank you guys, I love you all
P.S- Kalie and I think alike. Specially the whole theory with Leah and Jacob. Kassie you are hilerious, I have spit coke through my nose plenty of times listening to you.
Daylet
NEEDS TO BE IN MOVIE:
The part after the meadow where they spend the night together & she tells him ” I love you” & he says “you are my life now”. I think that part is a tear jerker/jump up & down part, haha but i might just be over sensitive.
I CAN LIVE W/OUT:
The part where shes unpacking all her stuff at charlies house. not really that much of an importance to be but then again the whole book is just AMAZING ! lol.
ps. I love your podcast & everytime i listen to it i cant help but laugh. =)
I NEED to see the entire Port Angeles sence every single bit form the book
The only thing i could live with out is the part at the beginging where Bella is Crying
I think this is great question! The hardest thing about adapting a beloved book to screenplay is that the story has many filters on it; the filters from the screen writer, the film editor, the director, and perhaps the studio if they (studio executives) have final cut. So we get our favorite scenes from a different perspective than we imagined while reading, or some scenes we thought weren’t as interesting while reading but just rock on screen based on how the scene is written, directed, edited and acted.
With that being said, I’d say what I’m looking forward to seeing the most is Edward watching Bella say his name in her sleep and sigh. Remember, Edward does say that is one of his greatest nights. Having the director cut the camera away to his reaction of Bella’s sleep talking at this moment will be *huge*! I hope we get to see the first time his rapturous joy from this feeling.
The least favorite, only because the scene is so painful is when Bella has to hurt Charlie to get to Phoenix. To me, the emotions in this scene will make it my least favorite, but I do recognize the importance of it.
the most important part that has to get into the movie is the medow scene because i am convinced that it will go down in history as one of the best, biggest, most amazing romance scenes ever. Also because its the defining moment in bella’s and edwards relationship and it helps explain how bella’s scent affects edward.
there is no scene that should be left out or that i would ever want out. Stephenie meyer wrote it a certain way that everything that goes on is important for the story. i know that the movie wont have every scene in it but i love all of it that i don’t want to change anything.
i absolutly LOVE your guys show! keep up the amazing work!:)
Rachel
NEED IT!) I’d have to say that they need to show the scene where Bella comes into the Cullen’s house for the first time and meets the family. They need to show the house in all its splendor and show the different personalitites of everyone and each room. They also need to show Edward on his piano playing his rhapsody and Bella’s Lullaby.
GET RID OF IT!) I don’t like they need the to have Edward watching Bella sleeping. I think they should just have it as a minor thing like in the book where it is barely brought up (just to show how serious and passionate Edward is wth Bella).
PS. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST TWILIGHT PODCAST EVER!!☺☻