MTV has a couple of articles on Bella vs. Hermione and one on their new Twilight quiz!
You know, a lot of people is fan of Hermione, and I one of them, but say that she’s better then Bella, that’s just a point of view. Because even tough Hermione is really independent and show that she doesn’t need a man on her side, and think Bella is braver than her, because, what some people call anti-feminism, I call bravery. It’s really hard you give up of everything for someone, you have to believe so much that you’ re not gonna regret and take a decision like that on her age, only show that she has a strong mind and that she knows exactly what she wants, and she’s willing to give up of everything she has to get that, that is to be with Edward for the rest of her life.That I think it’s awesome, for me it’s not a sacrifice at all.lol
luv your comment Ana C.!
but i get sick of ppl comparing these two completely different storys. i love both Hermione and Bella. they have very different characteristics
I really love BOTH Twilight and Harry Potter, but I have to say, in this case I think I’m Team Hermione. Bella is great too, but Hermione is just a better role model. She is smart, witty, supportive, strong, and feminist. I’m not saying Bella’s tale is anti-feminist, but, really, which one is more independent? Um…HERMIONE. Bella was (and I love Bella, truly I do) pretty wimpy before she met Edward, granted she became stronger, but it was because of Edward. Hermione didn’t need a man to bring out her strength.
these two lovely ladies are completely diffefent characters!!
Bella isn’t very wimpy…she stands up for herself, she takes on the responsibilities that no one else wants… ie: cooking for Charlie because he can’t, and taking care Renee because Phil wasn’t there yet, and by herself, she probably wouldn’t have lasted long…
Hermoine is a heroine in her own. She’s smart, she’s talented, but she also does what she needs to do to get along…
I really don’t read Harry Potter anymore…though Hermoine was always my favorite character…I was her for Halloween…twice…however, the two are only being compared because
1) HP and Twilight are both so quickly successful and have huge fanbases…plus, they are compared with EVERYTHING!!
and 2) Hermoine and Bella are both the famale heroines of the books…they are boung to come up together eventually…
but all i have to say is, why? why even bother? they are different characters. Different books. Different morals and views of life…I just don’t get it…
I disagree. I comeplety feel like I am Bella. I am a clutz and I constantly cook meals for my family and love to have sex with my Edward (lol). I haven’t ever related to Hermionie.
I love twilight (or i wouldn’t be here) and i really don’t think everyone as to battle over the two series like that all the time. MTV is making a comparision beetween the Hermione and Bella as a caracter..
I would prefer being Hermione, not for the power but its great determination and its mental force. Bella is sooo.. you know i always was discouraged when i read that she was so desperate to kill her self for everyone and stuff like that.. I know she really wanted to save them but she also liked the idea that she would be the girl who sacrifised her self and that’s what pleased her.. like she wasn’t that much important the way she was.. I don’t really like that attitude..
Be pleased with yourself girls
And before throwing me rocks lol.. just know i did love her attitude in the last one.. she began to like herself much and that made me happy.. it’s just sad she had to be a vampire to realize it..
Uh, no offense, but this article is completely retarded. HP and Twilight should not be compared. Bella and Hermione are nothing alike. For god’s sake, they don’t even live in the same world! I’m not going to choose between them. There are some qualities in both that I like and admire, and some that I don’t like at all. For instance, they’re both WHINY. That’s probably about all they have in common. My belief is that MTV is trying to recreate the “team” thing. Because Team Edward already won the Edward Vs. Jake one. So now they’re moving on to characters from 2 different books! Nice try, MTV. Not gonna happen. As I said before, it’s completely retarded.
PS. A little bit of self-promotion here :]
If you want to see more of my thoughts on Harry Potter Vs. Twilight stuff, or anything at all Twilight related, visit my blog/fansite at http://peacelovetwilightblog.blogspot.com
I believe I am #53 on Topsites right now. But not sure.
bella is reliant on edward ( see book 2: new moon) but hermione is really really smart and indepentdent
Mail (will not be published) (required)